Advertisements

Turkish Navy To Get 8 ATR-72-600 Planes Instead Of 10 As Originaly Agreed.

The heavy edited announcement from the Italian aircraft maker Aleina Aermacchi made it sound so nice, it was too good to be true.

Alenia Aermacchi has signed an agreement with Savunma Sanayii Müsteşarlığı (SSM), the Turkish Undersecretariat for Defence Industries to deliver two ATR 72-600 TMUA (Turkish Maritime Utility Aircraft) and six ATR 72-600 TMPA (Turkish Maritime Patrol Aircraft) to the Turkish Navy. The contract calls for strong industrial collaboration between Alenia Aermacchi and Turkish Aerospace Industry (TAI) for the duration of the project.

But the magic lasted only one paragraph.

The agreement is an amendment to a previous deal between Alenia and the Turkish government for the delivery of 10 ATR 72-500 ASW to the Turkish Navy.The most important change into the contract amendment is the adoption of the new -600 version of the ATR 72, the best in class of regional Turboprop. The original contract was based on the now out of production ATR 72-500.

I think the whole Meltem acquisition project should be thought in business and project management courses as a case study as an example how not to run a project.

When the Project started in 1998, CASA was still an independent company; the C-295 has just made its maiden flight and its ASW version did not exist even in the dreams of the CASA/EADS/Airbus Military engineers. After 16 years we still do not have any fully operational ASW planes for our navy.

And it gets only worse. Last week the Alenia announced that they were going to delivery 8 new planes to Turkish Navy. This is actually BS as two of the planes will be two ATR 72-600 TMUA (Turkish Maritime Utility Aircraft) which means in plain English that these planes will carry neither weapons nor any sensors. They will be used cargo planes.

Thanks to the agreement, the Turkish Navy will obtain the last generation ATR72-600 equipped with a glass cockpit as well as more powerful engines that guarantee best performance and supportability for the next 30 years.

The two ATR 72-600TMUA–already in the modification phase at Alenia Aermacchi’s plant in Naples-Capodichino–will be used by the Turkish Navy for personnel and cargo transport and will be delivered in June and July 2013 .

In July 2005 a contract was signed to procure 10 ATR-72-500 planes for ASW missions, to be used by Turkish Navy after the first part of the program involving the CN-235 planes was stuck.  8 years later, the Italians realized that they cannot deliver the 10 planes to according to the deal done in the contract so they had to renegotiate the whole deal. Now we get 2 planes less but a newer version of the ATR-72 plane as production of the  -500 variant is discontinued in the mean time.

As the newer -600 version has improved engines it is believed that the performance of the -600 will be superior to the old -500 version. But this fact has to be proven first.

I must give my respects to the PR people of the SSM and Alenia as they deserved it by making a good news from the rotten state of the whole Meltem Project; that is some spin doctoring.

Advertisements

10 Responses to Turkish Navy To Get 8 ATR-72-600 Planes Instead Of 10 As Originaly Agreed.

  1. Kevin Brent says:

    Even if the performance is superior, ASW is all about area coverage. The more aircraft, the wider the coverage, or the longer you can maintain specific area coverage with less frequent rotation of the same aircraft.

    • I totally agree. If the original plan was still alive we would have 6 CN-235 ASW + 10 ATR-72 ASW planes for the navy and 3 CN-235 MP planes for the coast guard. 19 planes for maritime surveillance missions and 16 planes for ASW missions.

      But now we will have 6 CN-235 ASW + 6 ATR-72 ASW planes + 2 ATR-72 cargo planes for the navy and 3 CN-235 MP planes for the coast guard. That’s 2-4 planes less from the original plan considering if you can use the cargo planes for surveillance role or not. That is the state of our naval aviation after 15 years.

      • Kevin Brent says:

        Yes. And while they could use the cargo planes, they would not have all the equipment. About all those planes would be good for in a surveillance role is visual surveillance/identification, or maybe a close overflight to let a vessel know they had been seen.

        I know what you mean though. I am still trying to understand why our Navy scrapped the F-14 Tomcat for a far less capable fighter in the F-18.

  2. Pingback: Συνδυασμένη Άμυνα Στόλου: Μέρος Β’ | Defencegreece

  3. Pingback: Finaly: The First ATR-72 Maritime Utility Plane Is Delivered |

  4. Pingback: Συνδυασμένη Άμυνα Στόλου Μέρος Β’: Θέατρο Ανατολικής Μεσογείου | Defencegreece

  5. Pingback: 12 Years After The Contract Thales Finally Delivers Maritime Patrol Planes To Turkish Navy |

  6. Pingback: New Maritime Patrol Planes For Turkish Navy? |

  7. Pingback: Meltem 3 Project Reaches A Milestone |

  8. Pingback: First Photo Of Turkish Navy ATR-72 600 ASW Plane |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: