Greek Navy Performed Live Missile Shootings

8mOn the 16th February Greek Navy conducted an exercise with live missile shootings. The exercise was held in south east of Crete.

According to official website of Greek Navy:

One land based mobile battery fired an Exoet missile, one S-70B Seahawk helicopter fired a AGM-114 Hellifre missile, the fast attack craft P-26 Degiannis fired a Penguin Mk.2 missile. The special forces team on Degiannis even fired an AT-4 anti tank missile.

The Greek armed forces are conducting a lot live missile shooting during their exercises. I guess expending a missile that, has a very little shelf life left, is cheaper than reconditioning it. Missile shootings also boosts the morale.

According to the official website of Greek Navy the target of these munitions was the decommissioned corvette Elefthria.

By the way “elefthria” means “freedom” in English.

Greek Frigate Bouboulina Decommissioned

Lowering of the Greek flag on Boubolina. Photo: Official Hellenic Navy Photo.

Lowering of the Greek flag on Boubolina. Photo: Official Hellenic Navy Photo.

Today Greek Nay decommissioned one of her 10 Elli lass frigates F-463 Bouboulina with a solemn ceremony.

Like all Elli class ships the ex Bouboulina started her life in the Dutch Navy. At that time she was known as Pieter Floriz. She was transferred after 18 years of service in Royal Netherlands Navy.

She was commissioned in Greek navy in 2001 where she spend about 1,200 days at sea, covering a total of more than 148,000 nautical miles. Greek Navy conducted a mid life modernization to six of the ten ships in service. Bouboulina, Kanaris, Themistocles and Nikiforos Fokas which were not modernized are going to be decommissioned gradually.

Her hull will be probably used to supply parts for the remaining 9 ships of the same class.

Update On Nusret 12 And Mavi Balina 12 Exercises

The Mavi Balina 12 anti submarine warfare and Nusret 12 mine warfare exercises are continuing. The former is conducted in Eastern Mediterranean while the later is in Aegean Sea. My list of the order of battle for both exercises is still incomplete but I was able to get some help.

First I have received this photo. I thank my reader Mr Yıldırım for this photo.

A the superstructure of a sixth warship is visible at the right part of the photo. I am not able to tell exactly ship that is but I am confident that she is one of the two Rhein class tenders / training ships of the Turkish Navy A-577 TCG Sokullu Mehmet Paşa or A-579 TCG Cezayirli Hasan Paşa. TCG Sokullu Mehmet Paşa acted as the flagship of SNMCMG-2 earlier this year when the Turkish Navy was commanding the task force.

 Number Name Type Country
M-500 TCG Foça Mine Sweeper Turkey
M-501 TCG Fethiye Mine Sweeper Turkey
M-516 TCG Sığacık Mine Sweeper Turkey
M-1064 FGS Grömitz Mine Hunter Germany
M-5559 ITS Viareggo Mine Hunter Italy
M-111 HMS Blyth Mine Hunter UK
M-276 TCG Ayvalık Mine Hunter Turkey
A-57X TCG Unidentified Tender Turkey
M-61 HS Evniki Mine Hunter Greece

Second I have received this comment. I thank my reader Herr Leif for this information.

 Number Name Type Country
F-217 FGS Bayern Frigate Germany
F-570 ITS Maestrale Frigate Italy
F-495 TCG Gediz Frigate Turkey
DDG-98 USS Forrest Sherman Destroyer USA
F-252 PNS Shamsheer Frigate Pakistan
F-244  TCG Barbaros Frigate Turkey
Unidentified Turkey
Unidentified Turkey
S- Unidentified Submarine Turkey
S- Unidentified Submarine Turkey
S- Unidentified Submarine Turkey

About Nusret 12 And Mavi Balina 12 Exercises

Turkish Navy is conducting two naval exercises simultaneously. One is Nusret 2012 mine warfare exercise is held in the Aegean with the participation of NATO’s SNMCMG-2 and Turkish, Greek and US naval units. Below is the order of battle for this exercise as far as I could find.

 Number Name Type Country
M-500 TCG Foça Mine Sweeper Turkey
M-501 TCG Fethiye Mine Sweeper Turkey
M-516 TCG Sığacık Mine Sweeper Turkey
M-1064 FGS Grömitz Mine Hunter Germany
M-5559 ITS Viareggo Mine Hunter Italy
M-111 HMS Blyth Mine Hunter UK
M-276 TCG Ayvalık Mine Hunter Turkey
Unidentified USA
M-61 HS Evniki Mine Hunter Greece

The second naval exercise Mavi Balina 2012 is held in Eastern Mediterranean with the participation of NATO’s SNMG-2, Pakistani, US and Turkish naval units and airplanes. According to Turkish Navy the total number of participants is 8 surface units and 3 submarines. Below is the order of battle for this exercise as far as I could find.

 Number Name Type Country
F-217 FGS Bayern Frigate Germany
F-570 ITS Maestrale Frigate Italy
F-495 TCG Gediz Frigate Turkey
DDG-98 USS Forrest Sherman Destroyer USA
F-252 PNS Shamsheer Frigate Pakistan
Unidentified Turkey
Unidentified Turkey
Unidentified Turkey
S- Unidentified Submarine Turkey
S- Unidentified Submarine Turkey
S- Unidentified Submarine Turkey

Reduction In Greek Armed Forces?

Düyun-u Umumiye Building. Now used as a highschool. Photo: © Guillaume Piolle via Wikipedia.

This beautiful building in the old city of Istanbul was the head quarters of Düyun-u Umumiye-i Osmaniye Varidat-ı Muhassasa İdaresi, between 1897-1933.

The Düyun-u Umumiye can be translated into English as General Debts or General Obligations was an administration established to collect the tax on stamps, alcoholic drinks, fish hunting, salt, tobacco and silk in the Ottoman Empire. Theses taxes were used to pay the internal and external creditors of Ottoman Empire.

Approximately 150 years ago “Sick man of Europe” , the Ottoman Empire was in financial crisis and was highly in debt to a consortium of banks. Neither able to pay the interest or the actual debt Ottoman Empire lost most of its financial freedom with the foundation of the General Obligations Administration. The payments of the debts of Ottoman Empires continued after the foundation of Turkish Republic and ended only in 1954.

I have told the story of the Düyun-u Umumiye simply because if a nations loses its financial independence, it loses pretty much everything.

According to Greek blog defencegreece.com IMF, EU and ECB want radical cuts in Greek Armed Forces.

The Troika calls for a 79% reduction in costs by 2015 for the Armed Forces

The data included in a question tabled at the Parliament, by the MPs of the ‘Nea Dimokratia’ party P.Kammenos and G.Stylianidis are shocking!

According to the medium-term program, by 2015 operating expenses of the Armed Forces will be reduced to 234 million Euros, from 1,112 billion Euros in 2009. The costs will be reduced by 79% compared with 2009 and 69% compared with 2011.

This means that the Armed Forces will be reduced to 1 / 6 of their power! It is paranoid to discuss such matters in this particular time, while huge interests and geopolitical games are played in our region, but “the government should decide whether Greece will continue to maintain its Armed Forces or no” says the question tabled by the two MPs.

The figures are truly unbelievable, but the numbers always tell the truth. Can the Greek government achieve this goal without significant impact on the fighting ability of the Armed Forces? Anyone who can claim this seriously, we are here to hear his arguments!

This question coincides with information that representatives of the troika want to have … friendly meetings with the Chiefs of Staffs on “how to reduce costs even further.”

Costs can be reduced and there are proposals, submitted two years ago, for closure or merging of units which serve no operational planning or decommissioning obsolete and now unneeded weapon systems. Both Ministers of Defence of the current government of PASOK, Venizelos and Beglitis, did not dare to touch these issues.

The Barbaros Action Plan

A few days ago the Turkish Daily Sabah run an article about the Barbaros Action Plan of Turkish Navy.

The owners of Sabah have a very personal and close relationship with Turkish Prime Minister Mr. Erdoğan. That creates a dilemma. Did Sabah run that article because they have received some insider information from sources close to Prime minister or did they wrote this article to appear niche to Ankara and to create a public opinion that supports Ankara’s latest measures against Isreal.

Any way the article has found a relative large audience on the internet and is used by many analysts pundits, bloggers etc as a source for their writings about the latest Turco – Isreali crisis.

But to be honest here is not much in that article beyond the very obvious fact that the presence of Turkish Navy in the Eastern Mediterranean will increase. Well this should be not news to anyone, ( including regular readers of this blog) as Turkish Navy is trying to increase its presence in the last couple of years.

SABAH is releasing an important detail regarding the Turkish Navy’s presence. Declaring their Plan B in response to Israel’s attitude following the release of the Palmer report, it turns out that the decision to “take all precautionary measures to establish further presence in the Eastern Mediterranean” is actually a part of an important plan of action.

In upcoming days, Turkey will begin to display a more active presence along with maritime components in both the east and southern regions of Cyprus. Within this framework, the number of frigates, assault boats, submarines and naval station planes serving in the Mediterranean Shield Operation which provide security in the Eastern Mediterranean will also be on the incline.

The Barbaros Action Plan, which aims to display the Turkish Navy’s presence in neighboring seas, now plans for Turkish maritime components to be in constant navigation not only in the Black Sea, the Aegean Sea and the Mediterranean but also in the Adriatic Sea, the Red Sea as well as the Indian Ocean.

In 2010, the first display of presence conducted by the Turkish Sea Task Group had the Turkish Navy paying visits to ports in the Aegean, the Mediterranean and the Adriatic. During that time the public of the nation’s visited were allowed to come on board to see the ships. The following is a list of the Turkish Navy’s activities in the Mediterranean, Aegean and Black Sea as well as the Adriatic, the Red Sea and the Indian Ocean:

Well Turkish Navy is maintaining a regular and strong presence especially in the Black Sea and Turkish frigates has been present in the fighting against piracy in Gulf of Aden since 2008. So far there is nothing new there except the part I have emphasized. And this was expected after the statements of Mr. Davutoğlu and Mr. Erdoğan last week.

I do not see anything really newsworthy in the Sabah’s article. It just states the obvious,  shares a little information about the ongoing operations of Turkish Navy and gives the plan a name.

MEDITERRANEAN SHIELD TO BE ACTIVATED: It turns out that there are new procedures being put into place to further activate the Mediterranean Shield which was first established by the National Security Council in 2006 in order to establish security in the region following the establishment of the Ceyhan region as a center for energy. Upon Israel’s insistence on continuous postponement in regards to the apology issue, the number of frigates in the Mediterranean Shield program will be increased from two to four, the number of assault boats from three to five and the number of coast guard ships will be increased from one to three.

This paragraph raises the questions a) Whether the Operation Mediterranean Shield was deactivated? b) If so when it was deactivated? As far as Turkish Navy is concerned this Operation started as a national mission in accordance with NATO’s Active Endeavor is aimed to protect the oil terminals in Ceyhan Adana and to provide a deterrence through constant presence in the SLOC’s  east of Cyprus, leading to Ceyhan. I think that this inconsistency is due to the poor wording of the journalist or his/her lack of knowledge about the active operations of Turkish Navy.

One important question never mentioned in this article is whether Turkish Navy is going to set up permanent task forces or task groups. Both task groups established in 2010 and 2011 were temporary organisations with a specific purpose.  The Task Group in 2010 sailed trough the Mediterranean including the Adriatic Sea and visited several African and European States. This year’s task group sailed through the Gulf of Aden and Indian Ocean. It conducted anti piracy patrols, escorted convoys and visited several African, Middle East and South East Asian States. In fact one frigate from this task force F-492 TCG Gemlik is still in the region. But the task forces are disbanded when their scheduled cruises ended. So whether Turkish Navy is going to create constant task forces is for me the question.

One of the main duties of Turkish Navy is to be present in any part of the world where Turkey has a national interest. This is why we keep a frigate around year for the last couple of years in Gulf of Aden: to protect the Turkish ships passing through the region among other nations ships. Current political situation forces Turkish Navy to be in Eastern Mediterranean.

Port Visits

CG-61 USS Monterey in Kuşadası.

The Ticonderoga class cruiser of US Navy, CG-61 USS Monterey arrived in Kuşadası, Aydın for a 3 day port visit.

USS Monterey is one of the BMD able ships of the US navy. Her cruise to the Black Sea two months ago,  a short time after Russia and NATO have failed to agree on forms of cooperation on the missile shield in Europe, caused protests from Russia.

USS Monterey will leave Kuşadası on 23rd August Monday.Kuşadası is one of the popular R&R destinations of US Navy. Another BMD capable US Navy cruiser USS Vella Gulf made a port visit in Kuşadası last year.

L-177 HS Rodos in Odessa.

On a separate occasion, the Greek tank landing ship L-177 HS Rodos is in Odessa, Ukraine for a 4 day port visit.  The Jason class ship can carry 300 troops and 4 LCVP’s.

According to the Ukrainian Mod website the Greek sailors at Odessa will conduct a number of different activities aimed at developing and maintaining close relations between the two countries.

The the crew of the Greek ship will, laying flowers at the Tomb of the Unknown Sailor, and attend a series of protocol meetings with leaders of regional and city authorities and officials of the military administration of the local garrison.

Greek Navy Said Farewell to 3 Fast Attack Boats.

Flag Lowering Ceremony. Official Greek Navy Photo.

On 10 June 2011 Friday, Greek Navy decommissioned 3 of its fast attack craft. P-74 HS Plotarchis Vlahavas, P-76 HS Ypoploiarchos Tournas and P-77 Plotarchis Salipsis.  All the three boats were La Combattante IIA class and were transferred from German Navy in 1995 and 2000.

P-74 HS Plotarchis Vlahavas was armed with Harpoon the reminder with MM38 Exocet missiles as main anti ship weapons.

Before the decommissioning The Greek Navy had 9 La Combattante III and 6  La Combattante IIA fast attack craft. Now this number is reduced to a total of 12.

These deletions were expected as cost cutting measures.

Click here for the official press release.

 

Greek Submarine Glavkos To Be Decommissioned

S-110 HS Glavkos

According to Greek newspaper Democracy, on 9 June 2011, the first Type 209 submarine of Greek Navy S-110 HS Glavkos will be retried after 40 years of service.

This submarine was also the first  Type 209 submarine ever constructed. Totally 57 Type 209 submarines were constructed for 11 different nations, making the Type 209 one of most successful diesel-electric submarine design since World War 2.

HS Glavkos received a mid-life modernization between 1989 and 1997 and was able to fire UGM-84D Sub Harpoon.

This decommissioning was expected as in March it was announced that Greece was to decommission a submarine and  3 Votsis (La Combattante II) class fast attack craft in order to save on equipment and personnel costs.

The Greek Navy did not made any public declarations about when the Votsis class boats will be retired.

Photo: From Strategy Report.

You reap, what you sow

HS Papanikolis, in Kiel at her builder in 2009

A new controversy regarding the Hellenic Navies newest submarine S-120 HS Papanikolis is making headlines in Greece.

HS Papanikolis, a German built Type 214 AIP submarine, for many years, has been the focus of political and economic conflict between Greece and Germany. A lot has been written about this decade long conflict which ended in November 2010 with the commissioning of the submarine into Hellenic Navy.

The latest controversy regarding the submarine has started with a article published in Greek weekly Epikaira this week. While I was not able to find the mentioned article online I can assume its content from the public response of the Helleinc Navy.

The article in Epikaira mentions a naval exercise with the participation of HS Papanikolis and S-111 HS Nereus some 4 weeks ago. HS Nereus is a 39 years old, first generation Type 209 class submarine. She has received a mid-life modernisation in 2000, including installation of flank array sonar, new inertial navigation system, GPS and ESM. During this upgrade the submarine was enabled to fire UGM-84 Sub Harpoon anti ship missile.

According to the article the old HS Nereus was able to defeat the brand new and ultra silent HS Papanikolis, and the crew of the older boat was given a two week leave both as a reward and as a gag order. The article also states that

Papanikolis occurred in many areas unprepared by being declared fully operational, while in the log of the submarine recorded more than 40 important or less important problems and shortcomings were recorded, which ranged from the ballast of the vessel and expanded to electronic equipment and high trace recorded at rival radar. The Chief of Naval Staff, Admiral Demetrios Elefsiniotis Navy, ordered to communicate directly to the German side to assist in resolving the mentioned problems and shortcomings.

Needless to say that the article made big news and a considerable upheaval.

In a written public statement, Greek Navy spokesperson Commander Adamantios Christodoulou, denied all the allegations of the Epikaira’s article and stated that this publication is full of false, untrue and defamatory information about the well-trained submarine Papanikolis  the operational capabilities of most modern submarine, the Navy.

Well this sort of bad public opinion about HS Papanikolis does not surprise me or should surprise anybody. Between 2006 and 2010 when Greek Navy denied to commission HS Papanikolis because of numerous shortcomings and defects, there was a continuous reporting and defamatory information about the submarine and its producer which shaped the public opinion constantly (and permanently I guess).

It would be naive to expect good news that praise the submarine just because Greek Navy had to commission her into service six months ago. Even if the Germans rectified the defects of the submarine the time elapsed is just to short to revers the damage done to the reputation of the submarine.
And believe it or not this is not the end of the problems Papanikolis has created. The bribery case is continuing on a separate but parallel course.

At least 120 million euros was paid in bribes by the German firm that struck a deal with the Greek government for the sale of four navy submarines, according to German court documents seen by Kathimerini

Two former executives of Ferrostaal, the Germany firm that was part of the consortium which won the contract, gave depositions in Munich concerning the kickbacks paid to secure the deal, which was worth just over 1.2 billion euros.

So the Germans admit their guilt and confess that they have paid kickbacks. The ball is not on Greek side. It will be interesting to watch what the prosecution in Greece will reveal.

The Greeks are reaping that they have sown.

For further reading:
Same Submarine Different Headaches
3 Ex-Ministers May Face Charges Over Papanikolis Deal
Submarine News Around The Region
Finally The End Of An Odyssey: Papanikolis Commissioned
Papanikolis To Be Commissioned At Another Day
Papanikolis To Be Commissioned On 15th October 2010
The Submarine Deals That Helped Sink Greece
Thyssenkrupp Is Selling Hellenic Shipyards
The End Of The Odyssey Of Papanikolis
More On Greek Submarine force
Greek Submarine Force

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 462 other followers

%d bloggers like this: